Your Guide to the Cost of Mailboxes for Your Historic Home

By Joshua Scheide | December 29, 2025

Your mailbox choice usually feels like a small decision.

It’s not structural. It’s not expensive compared to roofing or windows. But the cost can be surprising—ranging anywhere from $30 to $600 or more.

This guide explains what actually drives those mailbox prices for your historic home, so you can understand what you’re paying for before you install something you’ll see every day for the next decade (or much longer).

Whether you’re choosing a wall mount mailbox near your front door or a post mount mailbox at the curb, the same cost factors apply.

Material choice is the primary driver of mailbox pricing.

How materials can drive cost up:

• Manufacturing from durable materials like solid brass
• Using thicker gauges of material

How materials can drive cost down:

• Using less durable materials like plated steel, aluminum or plastic
• Using thinner gauges of material

What this means for your mailbox:

Material choice affects longevity. Materials like aluminum or steel will corrode or rust eventually, either becoming unsightly, losing their integrity, or both—usually within a decade. Solid brass will patina over time, and if cared for, will be around for decades (or centuries).

How manufacturing can drive cost up:

• Domestic production involves higher labor wages and benefits
• Hand-assembly and finishing processes increases production time
• Small-batch production runs require individualized attention

How manufacturing can drive cost down:

• Overseas mass production in regions with lower labor costs
• Automated manufacturing processes
• Large production runs spread tooling expenses across identical units

What this means for your mailbox:

You’re choosing between a product manufactured overseas and pulled off a shelf, or a product manufactured to your order (with a longer lead time) in the United States.

How design can drive cost up:

• Complicated decorative details (hand-hammered textures, applied ornament)
• Customization or personalization options
• Period-accurate reproduction (research costs, specialized tooling)
• Oversized dimensions for package delivery
• Accessories added on like newspaper/magazine holders, locking mechanisms, custom nameplates or address numbers

How design can drive cost down:

• Simple geometric shapes
• Designing for single-piece stamped construction
• Limiting options for sizes and finishes

What this means for your mailbox:

Period-specific details require more production time and specialized skills than simple designs. Standard sizes and stock finishes offer the lowest price point but limit options, while customization adds cost but allows precise matching to your home's architectural character.

Companies at the cheaper end of the price spectrum use less durable materials, manufacture a limited number of specified stock designs and are producing their product overseas. These companies prioritize a lower upfront cost with the tradeoff that the mailbox won’t maintain its look or structure over time.

More expensive companies manufacture mailboxes with historically accurate designs from durable materials, and they’re crafting those mailboxes in the United States in small batches. These companies ask for a higher upfront cost in return for a product usually designed to last for life.

Old California’s mailboxes fall on the higher end of the price range for historic homes, ranging between $250 and $500. They are handcrafted to order in our Southern California factory, and feature solid brass construction, historic styling and design, hand-finishing and options to personalize the mailbox to your home.

When you buy a mailbox from Old California, you’re not just paying for something that holds your mail. You’re investing in beautiful design that is meant to live outdoors year-round and age gracefully alongside the rest of your home, not chip away at its character.

Ready to find the perfect mailbox that fits your historic home? Shop the Old California collection.

Keep Learning

• What does lighting cost for your historic home?
• What does a rug cost for your historic home?