Our house is old but not craftsman style, but we chose this mailbox and love it! Very well built with drain holes on the bottom and thin rubber ridges so the lid doesn’t clank. We may put an LED light inside so the house numbers show at night because we no longer have them on our door, and the light we have is directly above. During the day they do show very well. Our neighbor asked where we got it, so there may be a twin order on the way! I would have preferred a locked style but got “outvoted.”